+- MetalworkingFun Forum (http://www.metalworkingfun.com)
+-- Forum: Machining (http://www.metalworkingfun.com/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: General Metalworking Discussion (http://www.metalworkingfun.com/forum-6.html)
+--- Thread: Any Logan Shaper advise? (/thread-924.html)
Pages:
1
2
Any Logan Shaper advise? - sasquatch - 10-18-2012
I am looking at buying a 7inch Logan shaper with the "Vari-Drive" speed control.
Anyone have any info on what to look for with problems with this type of drive.
Thanks.
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - f350ca - 10-19-2012
I have the 8 inch one. The variable speed drive works well but I think that is what makes the machine noisy. Have read other posts claiming the Logan is noisy, they blame it on the chain drive. Its not annoyingly noisy but louder than you'd think it should be. I've been going to tear this one apart to see if there is wear in the sheave bushings allowing them to wobble. I have a Rockwell wood lathe that uses a variable speed belt drive that is quiet.
The variable speed drive is very nice to have.
The machine seams to be well built, heavy for its size, you can make it chatter but have to work at it.
My only complaint on the design is the size of the dials, they're tiny, virtually useless. With the machine stroking just try and read the down feed dial. You need dial indicators on the clapper and table movement. Another project on the ever growing list is to make new much larger dials.
Can't really tell you anything in particular to look for but if its noisy don't be surprised.
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - Sunset Machine - 10-19-2012
Larger dials would be nice on my shaper too. What I do now is to turn the thing off, set the depth, and then power on for one stroke (actually three because of momentum, there's no clutch). I'm not real fond of shapers -- noisy, clumsy and slow is what they are. I could easily be talked into selling it (it's not a Logan).
Vari-speed sounds good, wish I had one but I'm not going to spend money on a VFD for mine. The problem is that each stroke takes time, and changing the length of the stroke means the stroke time changes (surface speed) and RPM changes are required in order to compensate. With a vari-speed, I think you could adjust it for a yellow chip quite easily.
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - TOM REED - 10-19-2012
Sunset down the road a ways if you are thinking of getting rid of your shaper I would be interested. tom
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - f350ca - 10-19-2012
Was just checking Sasquatch. The 7 inch isn't built quite the same. The photo's I saw show it doesn't have a slotted table, that might be a nuisance, and the table doesn't have the front support mine does, that could be built though.
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - stevec - 10-19-2012
I'd love to see pics of both showing the differences.
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - sasquatch - 10-19-2012
Well today i went back and checked out this shaper. I got it turned around to get some light , in all the kaos of a mess in this garage where it has sat for a number of years. Took the covers off and things seem tight and ok. It does run, but it is filthy. Also found one of the missing crank handles that were gone.
Does anyone know what the original colour of these shapers where???
Doesn't appear to have been repainted years ago, but this one is a beige or tan colour?
.
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - sasquatch - 10-19-2012
Sorry forgot to post that i bought it.
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - f350ca - 10-19-2012
Congratulations. No idea on the original colour, mine was brush painted sort of off white.
Here's a link to some info on them.
http://www.lathes.co.uk/loganshaper/index.html
RE: Any Logan Shaper advise? - sasquatch - 10-19-2012
Thanks Greg, info is always welcomed greatly.