+- MetalworkingFun Forum (http://www.metalworkingfun.com)
+-- Forum: Machinery (http://www.metalworkingfun.com/forum-10.html)
+--- Forum: Lathes (http://www.metalworkingfun.com/forum-11.html)
+--- Thread: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match (/thread-2191.html)
Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - tackit - 07-21-2014
Guys is this a good match. A Noga and the Fowler indicator?
Would a Noga holder without the fine tuning feature be better?
Thanks for any help
http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INSRIT?PARTPG=INLMKD&PMPXNO=12387651&PMAKA=326-1369
http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INSRIT?PARTPG=INSRAR2&PMAKA=307-3434&PMPXNO=8137956
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - EdK - 07-21-2014
You can't go wrong getting a Noga holder. I have the one you linked to and it'll work fine for you.
Ed
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - tackit - 07-21-2014
(07-21-2014, 09:36 AM)EdK Wrote: You can't go wrong getting a Noga holder. I have the one you linked to and it'll work fine for you.
Ed
Thanks Ed. The ones I use now are garbage.
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - EdK - 07-21-2014
I have that exact same setup. Both the Noga holder and the same Fowler indicator. I use them all of the time. You'll be happy with that combination.
Ed
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - PixMan - 07-21-2014
I also have the same Noga holder, with "fine adjustment at top" (FAT) and it beats my two Starrett No.657's, handily.
I don't use a Fowler indicator though. I have a Starrett No.708 and an Interapid 312B-4, those get the job done well and the Starrett was cheaper than a Fowler because I bought used locally.
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - tackit - 07-21-2014
Pix Man I have a Lufkin set of two dial indicators and accessories in good condition in their box my dad gave me.... but I wanted one like the Fowler just because I don't have one like it and it bothers me not knowing how they are to work with...
Check out this German made Mar from long Island indicator.com
http://www.longislandindicator.com/p235.html
You probably know they have a very informative website, good information for beginners to read.
After I build a new handle for my SIL's cultivator I'm going down in the basement and do some work on my small lathe. I hope the Noga will make it easier setting up the 4 jaw chuck.
Here's a pic of my 8 X 14 Chinese lathe
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - Arbalest - 07-23-2014
If you're looking at getting a Fowler check out this page first:
http://www.longislandindicator.com/p37.html
As tackit says the Mahr is a good indicator and at a good price at the moment.
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - tackit - 07-25-2014
I got the Noga and Fowler instrument today, it's very nice holder, the Fowler gauge seems to work smoothly too. It made return to zero about 30 times, it works fine.
I got all the measuring tools I have out to see if which ones will fit the Noga holder, It won't hold the Lufkin but holds the Fowler 3/8 barrel but it won't hold the 3/8 white face gauge.
I have to replace a belt and change blades on the Snapper and then I'm going to do some lathe work... I'm sure I won't have the holding problems I do with my other holders. I agree with you experts the Noga holder is a very nice tool.
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - PixMan - 07-25-2014
What I really like about my Noga like that one is that the arm does NOT move as you tighten it, and the fine adjustment is very positive too.
RE: Is this a good instrument holder and holder match - tackit - 07-26-2014
(07-25-2014, 10:35 PM)PixMan Wrote: What I really like about my Noga like that one is that the arm does NOT move as you tighten it, and the fine adjustment is very positive too.
It sure is a solid holder, I tried to make it move but it was as stable as could be.
Someday I'll get a top shelf indicator for it.
I'm still leaning the basics of machining, What upsets me most right now is I can't seem to cut a smooth surface.... I have to file and then use emery clothe to get a decent look.
When I see Tom's and you other guys work it destroys me. I use HSS bits thinking they are better for my small 8" lathe but nothing I do seems to work.